Argument Preview / Featured / Panel Activity

As we have been reporting, four cases being argued at the Federal Circuit in November attracted amicus briefs. One of these cases is In re Blaze Mobile, Inc., a patent case. In this case, Blaze Mobile appeals a judgment of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, which affirmed an examiner’s rejection of every claim of a patent during an ex parte reexamination. This case presents questions related to claim construction and non-obviousness. Notably, this case involves the same appellant and similar issues as the case we previewed yesterday, and this case will be argued immediately after that case. This is our argument preview.

In its opening brief, Blaze argued reversal of the Board’s obviousness decision “is justified because the Board’s decision is based on erroneous claim constructions.” Blaze contended the Board improperly construed “user login information/user authentication claim limitations so broadly as to encompass information . . . used for the entirely different process of authorizing charges.” Blaze maintained the Board’s obviousness decision related to these limitations “is not supported by substantial evidence under the proper claim construction.” Blaze also rejected the Board’s construction of limitations relating to the “identification of one or more products.” Blaze argued the Board’s construction encompasses the prior art’s “teachings of [] free music samples, which do not have prices and cannot be purchased” and “full music files, which are not both identified and requested to be purchased.” Finally, Blaze maintained the Board’s obviousness decision regarding limitations concerning interactions with a “remote management server” and a “transaction server” “disregards important claim limitations.” Moreover, according to Blaze, “the Board did not present any documentary evidence that it would have been obvious to modify” systems like the servers described in the prior art.

In its response brief, the Patent and Trademark Office contended “the Board’s interpretations are well supported by the claim language and the record.” On the other hand, the PTO argued, “Blaze’s proposed constructions” of the limitations “improperly attempt to narrow the meaning of the disputed terms without support in the claim language or specification.” Moreover, according to the PTO, “the Board’s determination that a person of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to combine the art has substantial evidence support in the record.” The PTO contended both prior art references “teach electronic credit card billing procedure,” and one “provides details to the standard” procedure taught by the other.

In its reply brief, Blaze noted the PTO did not “dispute that the claims would not have been obvious under Blaze’s construction.” Thus, according to Blaze, if the panel “agrees with any one of Blaze’s three claim constructions, the Board’s decision should be reversed.” Blaze argued its constructions are supported by “the claim language, dictionary definitions, numerous citations to the specification, and expert testimony.” Blaze highlighted that, in its response brief, the PTO did “not even mention the expert testimony or several of Blaze’s citations to the specification, let alone explain how the Board’s construction could possibly be correct in light of this evidence.”

This case attracted an amicus brief filed by Samsung Electronics Co., the party that “submitted the request for ex parte reexamination that led to the proceedings below,” in support of the PTO and affirmance. Samsung argued “Blaze’s construction is grounded in language and requirements that do not exist in the claims” and ignores “the clear intrinsic record” and “common sense.” Regardless, according to Samsung, should Blaze’s “incorrect” construction be adopted, one source of prior art still “discloses” the relevant limitation.

Oral argument in this case is scheduled to be heard on Monday, November 9 at 2:00 p.m. in Courtroom 402.