Featured / Petitions / Supreme Court Activity

Here is an update on recent activity at the Supreme Court in cases decided by the Federal Circuit. There are currently no cases pending before the Supreme Court that were previously decided by the Federal Circuit. As for petitions, since our last update, four new petitions were filed in a veterans case and three pro se cases; three waivers of the right to respond to petitions were filed in an Indian Tucker Act case and a pro se case; three briefs in opposition were filed in a patent case and a pro se case; two reply briefs were filed in patent cases; one amicus brief was filed in a Tucker Act case; and the Court denied four petitions. Here are the details.

New Petitions

Since our last update, four new petitions have been filed in cases decided by the Federal Circuit.

Robison v. Collins

In this veterans case, Robison filed a petition asking the Court to review the following question:

  • “Whether 38 U.S.C. §§ 5109A and 5121, together, permit the survivor of a deceased veteran to seek revision based on clear and unmistakable error, of a VA decision made during the veteran’s lifetime to obtain benefits due and unpaid at the veteran’s death; or whether the bar from Haines v. West bars survivors from obtaining review of error on the merits.”

Williams v. Collins

In this pro se case, Williams filed a petition asking the Court to review three questions.

Perdue v. Merit Systems Protection Board

In this pro se case, Perdue filed a petition seeking the Court’s review.

Ramey v. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.

In this pro se case, Ramey filed a petition asking the Court to review two questions.

Waivers of the Right to Respond

Since our last update, three waivers of the right to respond to petitions were filed in the following two cases:

Briefs in Opposition

Since our last update, briefs in opposition were filed in a patent case and a pro se case.

Apple Inc. v. International Trade Commission

As a reminder, the petition in this patent case presented the following questions:

  1. “Whether a patentee fails to establish ‘significant employment of labor or capital’ ‘with respect to the articles protected by the patent’ under 19 U.S.C. §1337(a)(3)(B) where the patentee’s investment falls into one of three uses listed only in §1337(a)(3)(C).”
  2. “Whether the Federal Circuit’s affirmance of an agency decision where (1) the court’s rationale does not appear in the agency’s opinion and (2) the agency’s result was not required by law is contrary to SEC v. Chenery Corp., 318 U.S. 80 (1943), and its progeny.”

Now, in its brief in opposition, the government argues Petitioner’s contention that the Federal Circuit “misconstrued the economic prong of Section 337’s domestic-industry requirement . . . does not warrant this Court’s review.” The government suggests “subparagraph (C) merely specifies an additional way to satisfy Section 337’s domestic-industry requirement” and “does not narrow the scope of subparagraph (B).” Moreover, the government asserts, “Petitioner’s contention that the court of appeals violated Chenery also does not warrant further review.”

Respondents Masimo and Cercacor Laboratories also submitted a brief in opposition to the petition. They contend “Apple has forfeited its statutory interpretation argument.” Regardless, they argue, “Apple’s statutory interpretation argument seeks to improperly narrow the plain language of the statute by limiting the types of employment of ‘labor or capital’ that can be counted under Subsection (B).” Lastly, they claim, “Apple incorrectly contends that the Federal Circuit affirmed the Commission’s decision on grounds not adopted by the Commission.” As a result, they say, “the Federal Circuit did not violate Chenery.”

Isaacson v. National Veterans Legal Services Program

As a reminder, the petition in this pro se case presented the following question:

  • “May district courts, consistent with the common-fund doctrine of Greenough and Pettus, and without authorization by statute or rule, approve payments from class-action common-fund settlement funds to reward litigants for serving as representative plaintiffs?”

Now, in its brief in opposition, the respondents point out how the Court recently “denied a petition by the same pro se objector raising the same question as in this case.” Furthermore, the respondents contend, “there is simply no need for this Court’s intervention” because “the question presented is of little practical importance.” Lastly, the respondents point out how “Isaacson’s argument on the merits rests entirely on two nineteenth-century cases that predate the class action device.”

Reply Briefs

Since our last update, reply briefs were filed in two patent cases.

Federal Express Corp. v. Qualcomm Inc.

As a reminder, the petition in this case presented the following question:

  • “Does 35 U.S.C. § 314(d) bar judicial review of the Patent Office’s refusal to determine whether a petition identifies all real parties in interest when § 312(a)(2) authorizes the Office to consider petitions ‘only if’ they identify ‘all’ such parties?”

In its brief in opposition, Qualcomm argued “FedEx’s narrow challenge . . . has no ongoing effect since the PTO has changed the specific policy of which FedEx complains and there is thus no likelihood that the issue will ever recur in the foreseeable future.” Moreover, Qualcomm argued, “the Federal Circuit merely followed this Court’s straightforward precedents in finding that § 312(d) barred review of a non-merits argument that FedEx made in opposing [inter partes review] institution and that was rejected by the Board in granting institution.”

In its own brief in opposition, the United States contended the Federal Circuit “correctly recognized that petitioner’s ‘challenges grounded in § 312(a)(2) fall within § 314(d)’s scope and are thus unreviewable.’” Furthermore, the United States argued, the “USPTO’s recent return to its original interpretation of 35 U.S.C. 312(a)(2) has . . . greatly reduced the significance of petitioner’s claims, and this case would be a poor vehicle to address them in any event.”

Now, in its reply brief, Federal Express argues “neither case [cited by the respondents] precludes review of an agency’s refusal to obey statutory commands.” Furthermore, Federal Express says, while the respondents “claim the Office’s change in procedure ‘greatly reduce[s]’ if not ‘precludes’ the chance this issue arises again, . . . neither Respondent acknowledges . . . how the Office could reverse course again tomorrow.” According to Federal Express, “nothing in any statute or Court precedent precludes judicial review of these errors, and nothing in any fair sense of justice does either.”

Centripetal Networks, LLC v. Cisco Systems, Inc.

As a reminder, the petition in this case presented the following question:

  • “Whether a court, without providing notice, may adopt a new, dispositive, materially different claim construction after the evidentiary record is closed, and without permitting supplemental briefing or a meaningful opportunity to be heard.”

In its brief in opposition, Cisco Systems said “Centripetal had notice of the district court’s ultimate construction” of a first patent and “the record shows that Centripetal was repeatedly heard on it.” As for a second patent, it continued, “Centripetal does not even claim a lack of notice, and the Federal Circuit held that Centripetal forfeited the construction it now advances.” Moreover, Cisco Systems argued, “Centripetal’s real disagreement . . . is with the Federal Circuit’s claim construction in a nonprecedential opinion,” and that “is not a question warranting this Court’s review.”

Now, in its reply brief, Centripetal Networks argues “Cisco’s response conflates notice of an opponent’s argument with notice of a court’s new claim construction.” Furthermore, it contends, “the error was more than mere lack of notice because Centripetal had reason to affirmatively rely on Judge Morgan’s February 2020 Markman order.” Finally, Centripetal claims, “the petition presents the correct legal question, which is not fact bound.”

Amicus Brief

Since our last update, Esther Jenke, Nina Nelson, and Arianna Poli filed an amicus brief supporting the petitioner in Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Kansas City v. United States, a Tucker Act case. As a reminder, the petition in this case presented the following question:

  • “The question presented is whether this Court should overrule John R. Sand & Gravel Co. v. United States and hold that Section 2501 is nonjurisdictional and subject to equitable tolling.”

Denials

Since our last update, the Supreme Court denied petitions in the following cases: