Yesterday, the Federal Circuit announced the release of materials in the ongoing investigation of Judge Newman’s fitness to serve on the court. The materials include expert reports, deposition transcripts, and orders of the Special Committee investigating Judge Newman. Notably, the materials also include a “Report & Recommendation” filed yesterday. As it explains, the report and recommendation “details the Committee’s findings which lead it to conclude: (i) that there is a reasonable basis to order full neuropsychological testing by a provider selected by the Committee; (ii) that Judge Newman’s continued refusal to cooperate with the Committee’s investigation by undergoing that testing constitutes continuing misconduct; and (iii) that the Judicial Council should renew the sanction of suspending Judge Newman from hearing cases for a period of one year.” Here is the full text of the announcement with links to the materials.
Pursuant to Judge Newman’s request under Rule 23(b)(7) and pursuant to Rule 23(b)(8), the materials below are being released. Any reference to Judge Newman’s medical information contained in these documents is consistent with Judge Newman’s own filings and disclosure which she has requested be released. At her request, Judge Newman’s underlying medical records will not be released.
- July 28, 2025 Report and Recommendation of the Special Committee
- July 24, 2025 Redacted Transcript
- July 21, 2025 Response
- June 20, 2025 Dr. Filler Deposition Transcript
- June 17, 2025 Dr. DeRight Deposition Transcript
- June 6, 2025 Dr. Noble Deposition Transcript
- May 30, 2025 Dr. Johnson Deposition Transcript
- May 19, 2025 Order
- May 14, 2025 Dr. Carney Deposition Transcript
- May 9, 2025 Dr. Rothstein Deposition Transcript
- April 11, 2025 Dr. Noble Supplemental Report
- April 11, 2025 Dr. DeRight Supplemental Report
- March 23, 2025 Dr. Filler Supplemental Report
- March 5, 2025 Order
- March 3, 2025 Letter
- February 26, 2025 Order
- February 20, 2025 Response
Prior documents in this matter can be found on the court’s website. Neither the Judicial Council, Special Committee, nor the court are providing any additional statements at this time.