Preseault v. United States

 
APPEAL NO.
93-5067, 93-5068
OP. BELOW
CFC
SUBJECT
Tucker Act
AUTHOR
Plager

Question(s) Presented

“In brief, the issue in this case is whether the conversion, under the authority of the Rails-to-Trails Act and by order of the Interstate Commerce Commission, of a long unused railroad right-of-way to a public recreational hiking and biking trail constituted a taking of the property of the owners of the underlying fee simple estate.”

Holding

“When state-defined property rights are destroyed by the Federal Government’s preemptive power in circumstances such as those here before us, the owner of those rights is due just compensation.”