Honeywell Int’l Inc. v. Hamilton Sundstrand Corp.

 
APPEAL NO.
02-1005, 02-1082
OP. BELOW
DCT
SUBJECT
Patent
AUTHOR
Dyk

Question(s) Presented

Does rewriting dependent claims into independent form, coupled with the cancellation of the original independent claims, create a presumption of prosecution history estoppel?

Holding

“[W]e hold that the rewriting of dependent claims into independent form coupled with the cancellation of the original independent claims creates a presumption of prosecution history estoppel. Accordingly we vacate the judgment of infringement and remand for determination of whether Honeywell can rebut the presumption of surrender under Festo.”